In the resolution of standard essential patent (SEP) disputes, anti-suit injunctions (ASIs) are an important tool used by courts in many countries to address international parallel litigation and safeguard judicial sovereignty. Courts in multiple jurisdictions have issued ASIs in SEP cases on various grounds. Among them, the "three-step test" developed by U.S. courts through judicial precedents is one of the important reference standards for assessing the appropriateness of an ASI. This standard, constructed through the Unterweser, Gallo, and Applied Medical cases, forms an evaluative framework for ASIs, clarifying the logical chain and key review points for their application, and providing crucial guidance for resolving jurisdictional conflicts in international parallel litigation involving SEPs.
I. The Foundation of the Three-Step Test: The Unterweser Case's Innovation of Traditional Factors
In the development of the three-step test, the Unterweser case holds an important position. It innovated traditional factors and applied them in the review of an ASI, laying a solid foundation for the subsequent refinement and development of the entire framework. The core dispute in Unterweser arose from a towage contract between the German company Unterweser and the U.S. company Zapata. The contract stipulated that disputes be resolved by the courts in London, England. However, after the drilling platform was damaged during towage, Zapata breached the jurisdiction clause and sued in a Florida state court in the United States. Unterweser then sued in the London court as agreed and applied to the U.S. court to stay or dismiss the proceedings. The key issue was whether a U.S. admiralty court has the power to enjoin a party from litigating in a foreign court, and how to determine the conditions for applying an ASI.
Traditionally, the four factors weighed by courts of equity in deciding whether to issue an injunction were whether the foreign litigation (1) would frustrate the policy of the forum; (2) was vexatious or oppressive; (3) threatened the in rem or quasi in rem jurisdiction of the enjoining court; or (4) would prejudice other equitable considerations. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals (hereinafter "the appellate court") systematically applied the four-factor analysis for the first time in this case,[1] and after modification by the U.S. Supreme Court, fundamentally innovated the traditional framework,[2] laying the foundation for the three-step test.
"Frustration of Forum Policy" Determination: The appellate court initially held that the exculpatory clause in the contract—which exempted the tug owner from liability for negligence—was invalid as contrary to U.S. maritime public policy, and further argued that the jurisdiction clause should likewise be invalid. However, the U.S. Supreme Court pointed out that the public policy established in the Bisso case applied only to domestic U.S. towage operations, aimed at preventing unequal bargaining power and negligent conduct. The present case was an international commercial transaction, there was no evidence of bargaining coercion, and the London court was a neutral and professional admiralty court; domestic policy could not be used to negate an international agreement. This finding strictly limited the scope of application of public policy, preventing it from becoming a pretext for evading international contractual obligations.
"Vexatious/Oppressive Litigation" Determination: The appellate court held that Unterweser's litigation in England would "disrupt the purpose of centralized handling of the limitation of liability proceedings" and impose a "double litigation burden" on Zapata, constituting oppressive litigation. However, the Supreme Court rebutted that Zapata was the first to breach the jurisdiction clause by suing in a non-agreed forum, and its conduct better fit the definition of "vexatious," while the London court had admiralty jurisdiction and the parties should be bound by their contractual agreement. This determination linked the finding of "vexatiousness" to whether the party complied with contractual obligations, rather than simply using the geographical location of the litigation as the criterion.
"Jurisdictional Threat" Review: The appellate court argued that a party's initiation of parallel proceedings in a foreign court would undermine the exclusive jurisdiction of the U.S. court. However, the Supreme Court pointed out that the traditional view of "excluded jurisdiction" was an "outdated legal fiction," and that the key was whether the parties' legitimate expectations were respected—in this case, no one denied that the court had jurisdiction over Zapata's lawsuit, but the court should prioritize enforcing the freely negotiated jurisdiction clause rather than expanding its own jurisdiction.
"Reasonable Consideration and Litigation Convenience" Consideration: The appellate court argued that the U.S. court was more efficient because most evidence and witnesses were in the United States. The Supreme Court explicitly reversed the burden of proof, requiring Zapata, which sought to evade contractual obligations, to prove that litigation in London would "severely deprive it of its right to be heard," and that foreseeable costs such as "transporting witnesses and increased expenses" were insufficient grounds for invalidating the clause, while presuming that forum selection clauses in international commercial contracts are "prima facie valid."
The Unterweser case broke the rigid thinking of traditional ASI review. It no longer presumed clause validity as invalid but shifted to a presumption of validity, while transferring the burden of proof to the party opposing enforcement of the clause, setting a higher threshold for the "reasonableness" determination and strictly limiting the scope of application of domestic public policy. These measures provided the elemental foundation for the subsequent construction of the three-step test, clarifying the core principle of "respecting international commercial contracts and balancing party expectations with judicial order."
II. The Embryonic Form of the Three-Step Test: The Gallo Case's Systematization of the Review Framework
The Gallo case is the key case that integrated the three-step test from "scattered application" into a "framework-based application." In this case, the distribution agreement between the U.S. liquor giant Gallo and the Ecuadorian distributor Andina stipulated that disputes would be governed by California law and subject to the jurisdiction of California courts. After a dispute arose in 2004 over goods delivery and exclusive distribution rights, Andina ignored the agreement and, relying on Ecuador's repealed Decree No. 1038-A, sued Gallo in an Ecuadorian court, seeking $75 million in damages. Andina used an "oral summary procedure" to compress Gallo's time for evidence and defense, and through fraudulent means appointed an inexperienced "property curator" to represent Gallo, causing Gallo to miss its opportunity to defend. Gallo then sued in a California court, seeking a declaration that the termination was lawful and applying for an ASI. The district court refused to issue the ASI on grounds of "international comity," and Gallo appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.
The Ninth Circuit first clarified the distinction between a "preliminary injunction" and an "anti-suit injunction": a preliminary injunction aims to maintain the status quo pending the outcome of the case, with the core being the assessment of likelihood of success on the merits and irreparable harm; an ASI aims to resolve international parallel litigation and maintain a balance between forum policy and judicial comity, with review standards independent of traditional preliminary injunctions. This distinction corrected the district court's logical error and cleared the obstacle of standard confusion for the construction of the three-step test.[3]
On this basis, the court first proposed the three-step test framework and applied it to the analysis of this case.
Step One: Determination of Party and Dispute Identity and the Preclusive Effect of the Prior Action. In this case, the district court held that the causes of action in the California and Ecuadorian proceedings were "different," because the former was based on contract performance while the latter was based on Ecuadorian decree. However, the appellate court pointed out that the core of both cases centered on "the dispute over performance of the 1987 distribution agreement"; the Ecuadorian decree invoked by Andina had been repealed, and the agreement expressly stipulated the application of California law. Even if foreign law needed to be applied, U.S. courts could apply foreign law pursuant to Rule 44.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure without relying on foreign courts. Therefore, the parties and the substance of the dispute were the same in both cases, and the court could render a dispositive adjudication of the dispute in the California action, satisfying the first step.
Step Two: Review of Whether the Foreign Litigation Satisfies at Least One "Unterweser Factor." The court found that Andina's conduct satisfied two factors simultaneously: first, "frustration of forum policy"—supporting the enforcement of freely negotiated forum selection clauses is a "strong public policy" of the United States, and Andina's use of foreign litigation to evade the agreement directly frustrated this policy; second, "vexatious and oppressive litigation"—Andina's use of a repealed decree, fraudulent appointment of a representative, and compression of procedural deadlines deprived Gallo of its legitimate right to defend, constituting typical oppressive litigation.
Step Three: Assessment of the ASI's Impact on International Comity. The court stated that "comity is not an absolute obligation." This case involved a private commercial dispute with no Belgian government involvement; the ASI would only restrain Andina's litigation conduct and would not interfere with the Ecuadorian court's jurisdiction. The district court's view of "first-to-file priority" was erroneous—if parties were allowed to evade jurisdiction clauses by racing to file in foreign courts, it would instead provoke retaliation from other countries and ultimately harm international comity. Moreover, the agreement stipulated the application of California law; even if the applicability of the Ecuadorian decree needed to be determined, U.S. courts had the capacity to do so without relying on the Ecuadorian court. Therefore, the ASI's impact on comity was tolerable.
The Gallo case integrated the scattered factors from multiple ASI cases after Unterweser into a "three-step progressive" review framework, clarifying the logical sequence and key review points of each step, and providing a systematic foundation for the subsequent refinement of the three-step test in the Applied Medical case.
III. The Refinement of the Three-Step Test: The Applied Medical Case's Detailing and Clarification of Standards
The Applied Medical case is the key precedent that took the three-step test from its "embryonic form" to a more refined state. In this case, the California company Applied Medical and the Dutch company Surgical entered into a distribution agreement under which Surgical would exclusively distribute Applied's products in Belgium, the Netherlands, and Luxembourg. The agreement expressly provided that disputes would be governed by California law and subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of California courts; the agreement could be terminated with 90 days' notice, and termination would not give rise to liability for lost profits, goodwill loss, or other damages. In 2007, Applied notified Surgical in accordance with the agreement that it would not renew the agreement. Surgical, relying on the "compensation right" conferred by the Belgian Distributorship Act, sued Applied in Belgium for goodwill damages. Applied then sued in a California court, seeking a declaration that the termination was lawful and applying for an ASI. The district court found the jurisdiction clause valid but refused to issue the ASI on the ground that "the Belgian litigation involved 'damages prior to termination of the agreement,' which differed from the dispute in the California action." Applied appealed.[4]
The Ninth Circuit systematically refined the review standards of the three-step test in this case, resolving key issues that had not been clarified in Gallo, making the framework more operational.
Step One: Refinement of the "Party and Dispute Identity" Review Standard. The district court required that the disputes be completely identical. Surgical argued that under Belgian law, goodwill compensation could arise before the termination of the distribution agreement and therefore differed from the dispute in the California court arising from termination. However, the appellate court clarified that "identity" means "functional identity" rather than "formal identity": all of Surgical's claims in Belgium presupposed "termination of the agreement," and Article 9(f) of the agreement had excluded liability for goodwill damages related to termination, and the California court had already found this clause valid; the "Belgian Distributorship Act" invoked by Surgical could not change the nature of the dispute, because the agreement stipulated the application of California law and U.S. courts could apply foreign law.
At the same time, the court clarified that "dispositive" does not mean substantive victory in the prior action, but rather that the prior court has the authority, based on jurisdiction and choice-of-law clauses, to adjudicate all disputes in the foreign litigation—the California court had already determined through summary judgment that the agreement was lawfully terminated and that Applied had no obligation to compensate, and this conclusion could directly negate Surgical's claims in Belgium; therefore, the California action was dispositive.
Step Two: Review of "Unterweser Factors." The court further emphasized that the value of jurisdiction clauses lies in "eliminating uncertainty about the place of dispute and ensuring the predictability of commercial transactions." Surgical, knowing the agreement's stipulation, nevertheless sued in Belgium, rendering the jurisdiction clause "a dead letter." If such conduct were permitted, the U.S. policy of "enforcing jurisdiction clauses" would be completely frustrated, seriously undermining the international trade order. At the same time, the court clarified that "severe vexatiousness is not a necessary condition"—as long as the foreign litigation violates a valid jurisdiction clause and frustrates forum policy, the factor requirement is satisfied even without extreme vexatious conduct, correcting an overly stringent understanding of the "Unterweser factors."
Step Three: "International Comity" Assessment. The court held that, given that this case fell within the realm of private commercial disputes with no Belgian government involvement, the ASI issued would only bind Surgical and would not interfere with Belgium's judicial sovereignty. Moreover, Surgical, as a Dutch company, was not a "Belgian domestic distributor," and Belgium had no "special protective interest" in it. The court pointed out that Surgical's conduct in evading contractual obligations itself violated the "spirit of comity," and preventing such conduct would instead help maintain mutual respect among international judicial orders. Through this in-depth analysis, the "comity assessment" no longer remained at the level of abstract principles but acquired more concrete considerations.
The contribution of the Applied Medical case lies in refining the review standards of each step of the three-step test, clarifying the connotations of "functional identity" and "dispositive," strengthening the core position of "forum policy," and detailing the specific dimensions of "comity assessment," making the three-step test a mature framework with rigorous logic and clear operation.
IV. Conclusion
The formation of the three-step test is a process of "practical needs driving theoretical refinement." Its core value lies in: first, balancing "party autonomy" and "judicial order" by presuming the validity of jurisdiction clauses and shifting the burden of proof to respect the parties' free agreement, while using ASIs to curb evasion and maintain judicial authority; second, clarifying the boundaries of "international comity," transforming comity from an "absolute obligation" to a "balanced consideration," avoiding sacrificing forum policy and party rights due to excessive comity; third, providing a clear path for resolving international parallel litigation, reducing the abuse of judicial discretion, and enhancing the consistency and predictability of adjudication.
As the saying goes, "stones from other hills may serve to polish jade." Currently, courts in various countries will inevitably frequently encounter international parallel litigation involving SEPs. The "three-step test" is not only the core framework for U.S. courts to assess ASIs but also provides an important reference for other countries in addressing jurisdictional conflicts, and has certain significance for reference.
References
[1] In re Complaint of Unterweser Reederei, GmbH, 428 F.2d 888, 890 (5th Cir. 1970),rev'd, 407 U.S. 1 (1972).
[2] M/S Bremen v. Zapata Off-Shore Co., 407 U.S. 1 (1972).
[3] & J. Gallo Winery v. Andina Licores S.A., 446 F.3d 984 (9th Cir. 2006).
[4] Applied Medical Distribution Corp. v. Surgical Co. BY, 587 F.3d 909 (9th Cir. 2009).
Comment