In 2026, the Milan Local Division of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) issued the first substantive judgment in the UPC's history to successfully uphold a FRAND defense in Ericsson v. ASUS. Although the patent at issue, EP'342, was found valid and ASUS was found to infringe it, the court nonetheless rejected Ericsson's request for injunctive relief on the ground that Ericsson had failed to fulfill its pre-litigation infringement notification obligation. This case treats the procedural obligation under the "Huawei v. ZTE" framework as a key factor in determining whether to grant an injunction.
Ericsson and ASUS had been negotiating a license for standard essential patents (SEPs) related to telecommunications and video coding since 2018. After failing to reach an agreement, the parties litigated against each other in multiple jurisdictions worldwide. In June 2024, Ericsson sued ASUS in the UPC Milan Local Division for infringement of two HEVC (High Efficiency Video Coding) SEPs. Subsequently, the Milan Local Division reached different findings on the two patents at issue: EP'673 was invalid, so no injunction issue arose; EP'342 was upheld as valid and infringed, yet the court refused to grant an injunction, ruling only on the declaration of infringement and damages.
The court found that Ericsson had failed to fulfill its due infringement notification obligation before filing suit, and therefore did not support injunctive relief. The reasoning of this ruling is rooted in the FRAND negotiation framework established by the Court of Justice of the European Union in Huawei v. ZTE: an SEP holder must send an infringement notification to the alleged infringer, clearly identifying the patent at issue and the specific manner of infringement, which is the procedural prerequisite for subsequent license offer and counter-offer negotiations. Pre-litigation notification is an independent, antecedent procedural obligation that cannot be cured through subsequent litigation conduct; if the rights holder skips this step and directly seeks an injunction, it may be found to have failed to fulfill its FRAND commitment in good faith, thereby losing eligibility for injunctive relief. The court also expressly declined to declare the patent a standard essential patent, which constitutes a further procedural obstacle to Ericsson's subsequent FRAND claims.
This ruling reminds SEP holders that a clear and traceable pre-litigation infringement notification is no longer a formalistic step, but has become key evidence for whether an injunction request can be sustained. This is the first time the UPC has refused to grant an injunction despite finding patent infringement established, on the ground of non-fulfillment of the pre-litigation notification obligation. This fully demonstrates that injunctive relief for SEP holders depends not only on patent validity and a finding of infringement, but also on whether they initiated the FRAND negotiation process in a good-faith and clear manner before litigation.
Comment